MARINETTE—One of two witnesses who saw a man walking from a double murder crime scene testified Wednesday in Marinette County Circuit Court. The other witness was served a subpoena in Idaho by order of Branch 2 Judge Jim Morrison.
The double murder trial for Raymand Vannieuwenhoven has had two solid days of testimony—Tuesday and Wednesday—as the state continues through its witness list. They include childhood friends of both victims, a person who was camping near the crime scene with his family and a handful of current and former law enforcement personnel and investigators.
Vannieuwenhoven, 84, Lakewood, is accused in the 1976 murders of a Green Bay couple who was camping at McClintock Park in the Town of Silver Cliff. David Schuldes, 25, and Ellen Matheys, 24, were shot and killed at the campground. They were engaged.
Matheys was sexually assaulted, but that charge has been dismissed because the statute of limitations has elapsed. There is no statute of limitations for the two first-degree homicide charges against Vannieuwenhoven.
During Monday’s opening statements, both the state and the defense mentioned a pair of eyewitnesses—Robert Swanson and Kim Huempfner—who were walking at the McClintock Park recreational area (near the camping ground) July 9, 1976, when they heard a gunshot between 2 and 2:30 p.m. The men got in their car and while driving south on Parkway Road, they saw a man walking down the road carrying a rifle in his left hand, according to the state.
Swanson, who lived in Goodman in 1976, took the witness stand Wednesday. He said he and his friend Huempfner, of Pembine at the time, decided to take a drive on a beautiful July day.
The witness said they visited Goodman Park and then the McClintock Park recreational area. They were at the recreational area when they heard a gunshot, he said.
Special Prosecutor Mark Williams asked Swanson, a hunter, if he could recognize the gunshot.
“It did not sound like a shotgun,” he said. “It sounded more like a .22 (caliber) or some kind of rifle.”
Swanson testified he and his friend, who was driving, got in their car and headed south on Parkway Road, toward the McClintock Park campground.
“Then something happened, “ Williams said. “What did you see?”
“Just past the campground I saw a man on the right walking with a rifle,” Swanson said. He said the man was “taller” with “longer” dark hair and was wearing a white or off-white shirt.
Williams asked Swanson if it was unusual to hear a gunshot in July, when it’s not hunting season. Swanson said it’s not totally unusual because there are people who poach.
“We just took it as somebody poaching,” he said.
He also testified that he and his friend saw a car backed in off the left side of the road opposite to the direction the man was walking. He described it as blue with Michigan plates.
Swanson said he watched the television news in the evening July 10, 1976, and that is when he learned of the suspected murders. Both he and Huempfner decided to contact law enforcement to tell them what they saw, he added.
Æ Co-defense attorney Lee Schuchart informed the court that Huemphner was served his subpoena Wednesday morning. He said he will keep everyone updated on the status of getting the witness in the courtroom.
Humphner lives in Idaho where he works for the Department of Security. The state said the potential witness has told them he cannot get off of work. On Tuesday, Morrison ordered both sides to get Huemphner in the courtroom to testify.
Shortly after lunch Wednesday, Schuchart filed a motion for a mistrial. He said when District Attorney DeShea Morrow was going through her PowerPoint presentation during questioning of a witness, a graphic autopsy slide of Schuldes was on the screen for several seconds.
“It was a pretty disturbing photo and it’s something that the jury saw and it’s not marked as an exhibit,” Schuchart said.
Morrison said he saw the photo at the time and he made a mental note to discuss it with the attorneys. It is not entered as an exhibit as of yet and it was only shown for at most 10 seconds, the judge said.
Morrow said the mistake happened because of a technical malfunction with her computer and as soon as she saw her slide show cycling through all her photos, she disconnected it.
“It’s obvious to me that you reacted as quickly as humanly possible, so let’s be clear about that,” Morrison said. “It’s also obvious to me that it was inadvertent.”
He said the court would do more harm than good by reminding jurors of the image. “That is a good way to re-ring the bell as loudly as we can,” he said.
Schuchart said inadvertent or not, the jury was exposed to a very graphic photo. Morrow countered that the photo will be introduced as evidence later in the trial, plus, she said, this is a murder trial and the jury will see autopsy photos.
Schuchart made a motion for a mistrial and Morrison swiftly denied it. He said the photo is not any more disturbing than some of the other photos that have already been admitted.
The state’s first two witnesses on Tuesday were childhood friends of the victims. Lynn Baumgartner of Green Bay said she knew Matheys since they were young. She called her “Ellie.”
“We were best friends since the ninth grade,” Baumgartner said. “She was like the sister I never had.”
Baumgartner, who attended Green Bay East High School and UW-Green Bay with Matheys, said she was supposed to be the maid of honor in her and Schulde’s wedding in the fall of 1976.
The witness described Matheys. “She was an excellent student,” Baumgartner said. “She was always quiet, reserved—I would consider her an introvert, intelligent, soft-spoken. Just an overall real nice person.”
Æ Steven Mommaerts of Green Bay, the state’s second witness, was a good friend of Schuldes. He said they met in Green Bay West High School and they became very close. They also went to UW-Green Bay together.
Mommaerts described Schuldes as a great golfer and an overall good athlete who went out of his way to be nice to others. As an example, the witness said he suffered a brain hemorrhage that caused one eye to droop and while most people avoided him, Schuldes sought him out to talk about the issue.
“He wanted to know what part of the brain it happened in and how it affected me,” Mommaerts said. “It made me feel good to talk about it—he treated me like a regular person.”
Mommaerts said his wife answered a phone call the morning of July 10, 1976, informing her that Schuldes and Matheys were dead. He said he was sleeping, but his wife told him about the horrific news.
“It felt like I was hit in the chest by a sledgehammer,” Mommaerts said. “I was in a daze.”
Other witnesses on Wednesday
Æ Marinette County Sheriff Jerry Sauve testified that in 2001, the 25th anniversary of the crime, the department made a push to get the case back in the public eye. Sauve, a lieutenant investigator at the time, along with a state agent, interviewed Swanson and brought him back to the crime scene.
“We wanted to talk to him again and see if he had any further recollections since,” Sauve said.
Æ Patrick Lutz and David Bartel, both retired employees of the State Crime Lab, testified about their investigation work in the case.
Other witnesses on Tuesday
Æ Patrick Fields of Montello, Wisconsin, testified that he was at the McClintock Park recreational area with his parents and brother July 9, 1976. He said he was just 11 years old, but he recalled seeing Schuldes’ purple Gremlin at the campground. He also recalled seeing a gray Plymouth parked on the shoulder of the road.
Æ Lance Timper of Marinette was a Marinette police officer in 1976. He said he and his girlfriend, now his wife, were on a “joy ride” July 9, 1976, and the excursion took them to McClintock Park. He recalled how a park caretaker told him of a male body (Schuldes) laying by the restrooms.
“There was a man laying on the ground,” Timper said. “He had blood dripping out of his nose and underneath him. His face and hands were turning blue. He had no pulse.”
Timper said the caretaker went to nearby Goodman Park to call 911, while he secured the apparent crime scene until rescue and law enforcement personnel arrived.
Co-defense attorney Travis Crowell asked Timper how many shots he heard when he and his girlfriend were looking for blueberries in the recreational area at McClintock Park. Timper wasn’t sure, but he said it could have been more than one.
The prosecution has stated Schuldes was shot once in the neck and Matheys was shot twice in the stomach.
Æ Former Marinette County patrol deputy James Jerue testified as to what he observed at the crime scene, while former dispatcher Connie Winchell testified about the 911 call she received about the crime.
Æ Retired Chief Deputy Robert Kohlman, who assisted in the investigation in 1976, also testified. It was under cross-examination by Schuchart when the topic of Huemphner, one of the eyewitnesses, came up.
Schuchart was seeking information from Kohlman and Morrow argued it was hearsay. The judge agreed.
“You’re trying to get that information in front of the jury through somebody else’s reports, which is the essence of hearsay,” Morrison said. “You’ve got to have somebody in the chair to cross-examine. You’re trying to avoid that and that’s not going to happen.”
Schuchart said he wasn’t trying to avoid anything. He said transcripts of the interviews with Huemphner are available.
Editor’s note: Trial coverage from Thursday and Friday will be in Monday’s EagleHerald and on ehextra.com
EagleHerald Staff Writer
MARINETTE—The water celebration and protest against the Back Forty Mine Friday drew people from myriad social justice organizations and indigenous tribes hailing from places as far as New Mexico, Utah, the Dakotas and British Columbia.
The event featured speakers from the Menominee Nation, the Indigenous Caucus of the Western Mining Action Network (WMAN) and the Coalition to SAVE the Menominee River with a keynote speech by retired University of Wisconsin-La Crosse professor Dr. Al Gedicks.
Individuals from outside these organizations also attended the event to learn about the Back Forty Mine and its potential impacts on the local community.
Illinois resident Jennifer Martinez drove to Marinette to join the celebration and protest. She said she first learned about the issue during a bike ride when she saw a Coalition to SAVE the Menominee River sign in front of Chief Oshkosh Native American Arts in Egg Harbor, Wisconsin. This piqued her interest, and she began watching videos and reading materials to learn more about the coalition.
“If this was in my backyard, I wouldn’t let it happen,” she said regarding the Back Forty Mine.
As an avid cyclist, Martinez decided to design and sell a cycling jersey with information about the Back Forty Mine that she hopes will incite conversation about the issue.
The event also addressed issues beyond the Back Forty Mine and brought together people who are contending with the impacts of mining across North America.
Tribal Judge June Lorenzo, who is part of the Laguna Pueblo and Diné (Navajo) tribes, came from New Mexico to speak at the event and share information about the mining that has affected her home community.
Lorenzo works in conjunction with the Indigenous Caucus of the Western Mining Action Network, which seeks to resist new uranium mining projects across the nation, and is also part of the Laguna-Acoma Coalition for a Safe Environment, an organization dedicated to protecting indigenous cultural sites and assessing the health impacts from past uranium mining.
The celebration was the first face-to-face meeting for members of the Indigenous Caucus since 2010, according to the WMAN. Lorenzo said the caucus tries to meet in places where they can help the host community take action on an issue. Meeting in Marinette to protest the Back Forty Mine, therefore, was a logical choice.
“It’s good to see our friends and relatives, it’s really good to see allies and the work and the movement,” Lorenzo said. “We’re grateful that we got to make a connection to this beautiful place.”
In addition to addressing the potential environmental and health impacts of the mine, the event highlighted the cultural significance of the proposed site and the Menominee River for the Menominee people.
Tribal Historic Preservation Officer and American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act designate for the Menominee tribe David Grignon spoke about efforts to add indigenous sites in Menominee and Michigan on a national register to block future attempts to mine in the area. He said the nomination is currently being reviewed by state historic preservation officers in Michigan and Wisconsin, after which it will go to the National Parks Service for consideration.
Prior to the protest, tribal members invited the public to observe a ceremony celebrating the waters of the Menominee River, during which the participants, who were all women, sang “Water I love you, water I thank you, water I respect you” in the Ojibwe language.
As participants of the protest against the Back Forty Mine made their way across the bridge from Stephenson Island to Menominee following the ceremony, passing cars honked in support and were met with cheers from the protesters. The atmosphere seemed to reflect the sentiments of what Gedicks claimed during his speech:
“This project has no social license to operate,” he said.
EagleHerald Staff Writer
MARINETTE—The Marinette City Council approved Wednesday the site access agreement giving permission for the Tyco Fire Products establishment on Industrial Parkway to utilize city property for construction of the new Groundwater Extraction & Treatment System (GETS). The Plan Commission also later approved the site plan application for the building that will house the system.
The GETS is a system that will extract PFAS from groundwater. A panel of representatives from Tyco Fire Products, LP (Tyco), the subsidiary of Johnson Controls, Inc. that is responsible for the PFAS contamination, first presented plans for the system before the City of Marinette this past June in conjunction with the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources (WDNR). The Advanced Building Corporation was responsible for submitting the site plan application for the building that will house the GETS.
The water treatment plant will be located on Tyco property, however, the 9 wells that will extract impacted groundwater will be dispersed throughout the city with 2 on Tyco property, 3 on private property and the remaining 4 on city property. Underground conveyance pipes will transport water to the treatment system.
The city also addressed concerns from Marinette residents regarding the aesthetic impact of the electrical boxes that will be part of the system, ultimately deciding to move some of the larger boxes inside the GETS building and make some of them smaller.
A group of residents at the Wednesday council meeting also requested a two week pause on the access agreement. They said they didn’t feel adequately informed about the potential effects construction of the GETS would have on surrounding neighborhoods and suggested that a separate meeting be held to address these concerns. The council, however, decided to move forward with the project without a pause.
With this approval, Tyco plans to obtain permits for construction of the GETS over the coming weeks and begin construction in Au
gust. It expects the system to be fully operational sometime in the first half of 2022.